A Taste of the Past
When I was growing up, the main meal was in the middle of the day. After that came ‘tea’ at about four or five, or whenever you got home from school. Tea featured hot black tea with milk and sugar; sandwiches, English style, meaning plenty of bread and butter, but not much in the way of filling (it could be jam, or Marmite, or perhaps a single layer of cheese or ham), and then something sweet - a piece of cake or a ‘biscuit’ (cookie) or two. ’Supper’ came later, and was something perhaps cooked, but anyway quite light. It might be soup, with more bread, or scrambled eggs, baked beans or mushrooms on toast - you get the idea. If you’re thinking we ate a lot of bread, you’re right - but it was good bread, brown or white, from the local baker’s, with a crunchy crust and a chewy middle - as far from flaccid packaged Wonderbread as bread can get.
All of that is actually just a prelude to saying that one of my very favorite main meals was my mother’s cheese and tomato pie. The tomatoes came out of a tin, the cheese was a good sharp English cheddar, and above and below that mixture was my mother’s delectable shortcrust pastry (I owe it to her that I have no fear of pastry making). We’d have the pie with new potatoes and at least one other vegetable, usually green. I loved the smell, and the contrasts - between the crunch of the top crust and the melting interior; between the sharpness of the cheese and the sweetness of the tomato.
So … fast forward to the present. I was thinking about making something special for a breakfast with Dan and Cynthia Lief this Sunday morning. They stayed with us last night after we all helped Frank Reece (along with friends and family) celebrate his 65th at the Cambridge Boathouse to a fabulous soundtrack of music from the sixties and seventies. Leafing through the new Bon Appetit magazines I’ve already mentioned I found a recipe for a tomato and cheddar pie - and needless to say I felt I’d found my inspiration!
If I needed any further incentive, I found it in the fact that the crust featured buttermilk - and I just happened to have half a carton of buttermilk in the fridge left over from the jalapeno cornbread muffins I’d made for Superbowl Sunday. I hate buying a special ingredient for a recipe and then wasting the rest of it … so here was the opportunity to put the buttermilk to good use, and take it off my conscience.
I’d meant to have the pie made before we went to the party, but for one reason and another that didn’t happen. So the dough, which was meant to chill in the fridge for an hour spent the night there instead, as did the tomato slices tucked up between sheets of paper towel to mop up their extra moisture. It’s a credit to the recipe that despite all that abuse of the ingredients, it came out really well. Modesty aside, it’s a credit to me that despite a late night and lots of dancing I was up by seven thirty to put the pie together and bake it so that it could still rest for its mandatory hour before we tucked into it a little after nine!
Unlike the cheese and tomato pie of my childhood this one is an open tart. But there’s plenty of browned buttermilk crust at the edges to replicate the crunch I remember, and the textures and tastes of the interior conjure up my family’s kitchen table, and the family gathered to share that favorite meal.
The recipe comes next!